Elizabeth Gaskell’s The Moorland Cottage: Summary and Thoughts on Chapter 8

Gaskell Blog © Katherine C.

Frank leaves for Scotland and Winter arrives, it’s dimmed days of rain and mist foreshadows a melancholy time for the family.

Without a gleam of sunshine to light up the drops of water, and make the wet stems and branches of the trees glisten. Every color seemed dimmed and darkened; and the crisp autumnal glory of leaves fell soddened to the ground.

Mrs. Browne’s spirits are low; Maggie fears its related to Edward’s extravagance but, knowing how it would pain her, asks nothing. The internal anguish of being kept half in ignorance troubles Maggie but when Nancy falls ill she focuses on household duties and nursing. Even though Nancy is ill she still see’s past herself and notices Maggie’s anxiety and keeps her in her prayers.

Painting by David Caspar Friedrich

Nancy is a quiet anchor within the story. She, as well as the Rev. Browne, helped form little Maggie’s good character. She set a good example and showed kindness and love. Yes, Mrs. Buxton cultivated Maggie’s mind and spirit, but perhaps it might be said Nancy cultivated her virtuous heart. Edward’s proud character kept Nancy at a distance and Mrs. Browne’s continuous indulgence fostered his selfishness and greed. It’s these two vices that get the better of him, and cast a dark shadow on the story, much like the Scotch firs upon the landscape.

Edward arrives in secret, trembling, wet. The police are after him and he clings to Maggie, his rock, who’s always gotten him out of scrapes. When he helped Mr. Buxton sell those profitless cottages, he took half of the payment for himself; a loan from a friend, he explains… never-mind that he didn’t ask permission, and which, of course, he intended to pay back. He forged Mr. Buxton’s signature on the receipt. This is why he was so upset over the news of Mr. Buxton hiring an agent, he knew his crime might be found out.

Painting by James Tissot

“Oh, Maggie!” said he, suddenly throwing himself at her feet, “save me! You can do it. Write to Frank, and make him induce his father to let me off. I came to see you, my sweet, merciful sister! I knew you would save me. Good God! What noise is that? There are steps in the yard!”

Edward sprints into the cupboard when Mr. Buxton arrives. Give up my son, he asks, in return he will drop the charges. She, and Frank through her, would be tainted by association, which would ruin his prospects for a brilliant career. Poor Maggie, to be torn between the love for her fiancee and for her brother.

It is hard all at once to be called upon to face the shame and blasted character of one who was once an innocent child at the same father’s knee… I cannot tell. Give me time to think; you will do that, I’m sure. Go now, and leave me alone. If it is right, God will give me strength to do it, and perhaps He will comfort me in my desolation. But I do not know–I cannot tell. I must have time to think.

A little afterwards Mrs. Buxton comes downstairs surprised to find her son, Edward cast his spell of eloquence on her, while Maggie goes outside to pray and think on what she must do.

Painting by Winslow Homer

4 Comments Add yours

  1. Kim says:

    I LOVE all the pictures you’ve found for this group read. That one of the winter makes me cold. 🙂

    1. Thank you, Kim! I tried to find paintings that reflected the moods or scenes in the chapters.
      David Caspar Friedrich is a very emotional painter. 🙂

  2. Diane says:

    Oh Edward – who would have thought you could turn out to be a no good trouble-maker – only everyone except Mrs Browne. Yes he committed forgery – but EVERYONE does it! It’s not his fault – he couldn’t help himself… oh, do the excuses never stop. Then when he does get into trouble, instead of taking responsiblity he comes home hoping his sister will bail him out. Maggie is shamed enough for the whole family and after giving up so much throughout the years she’s being asked to give up the only one good thing that is in her life.

    I don’t know how Maggie could even consider Mr Buxton’s offer – not for her no-good brother – no matter how “innocent” she remembers him being as a child (something I find highly unlikely).

    You could see this coming from the beginning. The bad brother gets everything and the good girl gets nothing and gives what little she has. Even her thinking is flawed. She’s not worried about giving up Frank for her own feelings but for his. Can someone be too saintly?

  3. bccmee says:

    This chapter is definitely moody and foreboding.

Share your thoughts!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s