Elizabeth Gaskell’s The Moorland Cottage: Summary and Thoughts on Chapter 6

Gaskell Blog © Katherine C.

Frank was praised by his tutors and headmaster as someone who could rise to the highest honor of church or state and while not ambitious, his father was for him. Mr. Buxton’s shyness in society made him averse to Frank’s requests of inviting school fellows and college chums to visit, now he regrets the loss of those connections; the best way to remedy it? Frank marrying a lady of good position and family. Erminia preferably.

And, in the midst of all this, fell, like a bombshell, the intelligence of his engagement with Maggie Browne; a good sweet little girl enough, but without fortune or connection–without, as far as Mr. Buxton knew, the least power, or capability, or spirit, with which to help Frank on in his career to eminence in the land! He resolved to consider if as a boyish fancy, easily to be suppressed; and pooh-poohed it down, to Frank, accordingly.

Front Garden by Frederick Walker

Edward comes to visit when he hears the news and is shocked at the engagement. His conduct and manners worry Maggie, she cans see his faults strengthening and growing. She wonders, where he gets the money to dress fashionably and go up to London? As if sensing the concern Nancy tells her that her wages, which used to punctual and regular, haven’t been paid for nearly twelve months– she doesn’t need the money but fears it means Edward is draining Mrs. Browne’s resources.

In many ways the relationship between Mrs. Browne and Edward reminds me of Mrs. Reed and John Reed in Charlotte Bronte’s Jane Eyre. Their bad habits, temperament, and path to ruination are very similar as are their mother’s blind admiration of their irrespective sons. Maggie decides to write to her brother hoping she can gently suggest he be prudent. There’s no reply until word is spread that Mr. Buxton has an agent, he asks Maggie to see if it’s true, it would be terribly unjust the position is rightfully his!

“It’s a confounded shabby trick if he has, after what he said to me long ago. I cannot tell you how much I depend on your complying with my request. Once more, write directly.

It is true.

The tensions between Frank and his father remain rigid. Mr. Buxton thinks his son’s love for Maggie is just a phase, he hasn’t seen anyone better and only thinks he’s in love– young fool!  But the young lovers are certainly not fools,

Old Farm Garden by Frederick Walker

It is nonsense to think that we are to go about the world, picking and choosing men and women as if they were fruit and we were to gather the best; as if there was not something in our own hearts which, if we listen to it conscientiously, will tell us at once when we have met the one of all others.

Maggie feels uncomfortable because she too thinks she’s not good enough for Frank and can sympathize that Mr. Buxton is aggravated by Frank’s visits to her. Knowing how much Frank really feels over the estrangement she encourages him to accept an invitation to Scotland. He decides to follow her advice, but not until he knows the new Mr. Henry will be a just agent.


5 Comments Add yours

  1. Diane says:

    Now here’s a twist – nobody is happy about the engagement but all for different reasons. Mr Buxton is only thinking of furthering Frank’s career (it’s not even about money as much as position).

    Mrs Browne and Edward are upset with Maggie for making Frank fall in love with her and ruining thier social climbing chances.

    Even Maggie can see everyone’s point of view except her’s and Frank’s. Will this girl never stand up for herself?

    And – besides all this going on – there’s a hint of money problems all centering around Edward – he easily abuses his own family and we know how “honest and Upright” he is – maybe it’s a good thing that Mr Buxton found an agent who wasn’t Edward.

    What will happen hext?

    1. I think Mrs. Browne and Edward might also be irritated that they, who always have tried to please the Buxton’s aren’t as favored as Maggie; it’s a presumption for her but it’s fine for them. I know, can you imagine the havock Edward would reek! Maggie does need to stand up for herself, but I think she feel lacks confidence in herself even though she is firm in her judgment & morals.

  2. bccmee says:

    Have to admit, Maggie is really dull in this chapter. She only wants to please everyone else. At this point, I wouldn’t blame Frank for choosing someone with more guts. Let’s see what happens when Frank goes on holiday and find out if the new agent works out for Mr Buxton. Poor Nancy too…going without wages for an entire year. I wish Ned would get his comeuppance. Mrs Browne definitely needs to stand up to her son and cut off his allowance and try to stop his thievery.

  3. Summer says:

    Through all her life, Mrs Browne and Edward have been diminishing Maggie; therefore it’s no surprise she lacks confidence. Deep down she feels Frank is too good for her; I hope she doesn’t regret encouraging him to go to Scotland.

Share your thoughts!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s